At Forbes.com, I look at news from Florida and what it shows us about who really controls voucher schools.
School voucher programs present a number of challenges to the tradition of public education in this country, and there are debates aplenty about those issues across the country. But Ron DeSantis has just demonstrated another aspect of a shift to voucher systems that is not often discussed.
This summer, Parents Defending Education, a conservative advocacy group, issued a report claiming that China has infiltrated U.S. classrooms. In the wake of that report, several politicians who use culture and education issues to rile up their voters, have picked up these claims and run with them.
Oklahoma’s State Superintendent Ryan Walters has put Tulsa Public Schools on the defensive by spreading PDE’s allegations. Walters had this summer forced out the TPS superintendent in his bid to have the state take over the school district.
In Florida, Governor DeSantis took another approach. Having determined that four schools that receive state school vouchers have “direct ties to the Chinese Communist Party,” he told the Department of Education to suspend their voucher eligibility.
It’s a stark demonstration of what a voucher system does to local control. In a traditional public school district, the state and the local elected school board both have their hands on the purse strings, but in a voucher system, the state holds every string on that purse.
Instead of a small, limited government, Floridians have a government limited to one small man.
Nominally it may be the case that state and local interests both control the purse strings of public schools, but functionally, if Florida withdraws state financial support from any public school, it will not be able to operate.